It had been pointed out in the comments on a separate post, that a number of broccoli seed retailers are, in fact, selling “Rapini/Raab/Rabe” seeds – marketed as regular broccoli speeds.

For those of us looking to buy broccoli sprouts, to then seed for their sulforafane content, this is a problem.

They’re actually a different family of brassicas than broccoli – despite looking vaguely similar when fully grown.

Until research says otherwise, we don’t know if they contain sulforaphane, so is worth watching out for (to avoid) when buying seeds.

The sprout house seeds I’ve linked to in a previous post, according to the seller, are “usually the cultivar Calabrese” (link) – which is a regular broccoli type that will contain sulforaphane.

Out of curiousity I bought both seed types (normal broccoli and Raab), *in case* it was possible to visually tell the difference between the unsprouted seeds (it’s very hard).

Click image to view full size. Seeds on the left come from Raab, the right two are different cultivars of “regular” broccoli. The main differences I could tell between the seeds (and I admit it’s very minimal), is that the Raab seeds are more uniformly dark (vs lighter browns for the others), and they are more uniformly smaller.

 

Above: Raab Seeds

 

Above: Cezar “Regular Broccoli”

Above: Tenderstem (Atlantis-F1) – “Regular Broccoli”

Conclusion

Whilst this was a worthy little experiement, I think you’ll agree that the differences between seeds are minescule, and it’s virtually impossible to tell the difference between the regular broccoli seeds and Raab seeds. Especially when you take into account the natural variation in broccoli cultivars. For example, above Tenderstem seeds vary slightly from the Cezar seeds.

What this ultimately means is that we have to trust the retailers, and make sure we double check on what cultivar they’re selling – making sure it’s not Rapini/Raab (which, as mentioned, is of a different family than broccoli).

Alex

Posted by Alex

3
Leave a Reply

avatar
3 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
  Subscribe  
newest oldest
Notify of
Inat
Guest
Inat

Thanks for sharing good info. I think I’ve been buying the wrong kind all along. 🙏🏻

Tom
Guest
Tom

Opps, misspelled: “Quick” seed, not “uick” seed.

Also add:

My 2 lbs bag had an expiration date of 4 years from my purchase (which is good because Im still spouting them.)

Dr. Tom Loo
Guest
Dr. Tom Loo

Instead of mason jars (too pricey) I just used the plastic takeout containers from the supermarket – which are about the same size and disposable – and drilled lots of small holes in the plastic lid for ventilation and drainage. I got my seeds cheap too, from FoodtoLive, which is on Amazon. They even provided me with a PDF certification of the lot my non-organic seeds came from. The doc states Brassica, Oleracea Calabrese. Other info: Orgin (USA); Harvest date; Lot #; uick seed (98%); Germination (98%); Purity (99.95%) Inert matter (0.05%), Crop or Weed (0%); Insect (0%). There are… Read more »