Rhonda Patrick – Broccoli Sprouts, Sulforaphane & Moringa

In this post we’ll run through:

• What sulforaphane is, and why it’s of interest
• How Rhonda sprouts broccoli seeds for their sulforaphane content
• The sulforaphane supplements Rhonda takes
• Moringa, and why she’s started taking it

The What & Why of Sulforaphane

Plants contain chemicals which are used for their self-defense (phytochemicals). Generally, plants evolved these chemicals to be toxic to organisms smaller than humans (for example pathogens). Thus, what may be toxic to a pathogen, has a lesser effect on a human. Ingested in small amounts, some of these phytonutrients exhibit positive effects in humans. But if you consume them at high amounts; they become toxic. This is referred to as hormesis, or, the hormetic effect – and is illustrated by the image below:

Bringing this back to sulforaphane, which is a product of a chemical reaction between glucoraphanin and myrocinase, the glucoraphanin itself is a plant-based phytonutrient that triggers a positive hormetic affect in humans.

Specifically, ingested sulforaphane activates what’s called the NRF2 pathway, which increases expression of a battery of cell protective genes, that regulate things like:

• Glutathione (GSH) – Essential in function of Glutathione peroxidase and GST for redox balance and detoxification.
• Haemoxygenase-1 (HO-1) – Redox-regulating, broad protection against oxidative stress. Anti-inflammatory and immune-modulating properties.
• Quinone reductase (NQO1) – A multifunctional redox-regulating and detoxifying enzyme, including protection against oestrogen quinone metabolites. Stabilises the p53 tumor suppressor protein.
• Metallothionein – Removal of heavy metals such as mercury and cadmium.
• Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor – Regulator of adipogenesis and central integrator of glucose metabolism, energy homeostasis and skeletal metabolism.

And that’s just a snapshot, NRF2 affects even more. This information comes via an incredible paper by Christine Houghton et al. (source) – which is highly worth reading.

As a result, sulforaphane is under continued study for its potential role in life extension, cancer prevention and more.

Sulforaphane and the Immune System
Recently, with immune function in mind, Rhonda’s been encouraged by a randomized double-blinded study that found sulforaphane from broccoli sprouts increased the body’s immune function against the influenza virus¹ . Specifically, it increased Natural Killer cells production of an enzyme that may enhance antiviral defense responses.

To learn more about Sulforaphane, see Rhonda’s highly detailed video on the subject.

Whilst the ultimate low-cost alternative to high end sulforaphane supplements is sprouting your own (see below), often this can be inconvenient. It takes time, preparation, and isn’t always possible when travelling or busy with work.

Since Rhonda had a child, her time is more limited, and at least for now she is opting to take sulforaphane as a supplement – rather than sprouting her own.

Below we’ll look at the best sulforaphane supplements on the market.

Self Grown Broccoli Sprouts

When Rhonda has the time, she opts to get her sulforaphane through self-grown broccoli sprouts. Sprouts are easy to grow with a bit of initiative. To emulate Rhonda’s exact broccoli sprout growing setup you’ll want:

• Ball Mason jars – specifically quart size, wide mouth
• Sprouter lids – wide mouth to fit the Ball jars
• Organic broccoli sprout seeds – a good example being Sprout House Organic Non-GMO

See Rhonda’s IG post for the size of mason jars she uses, and see her video on heating sprouts for brand of jars. She was previously running 6 jars in rotation, freezing them in ziplocks as soon as they’re ready. However, more recently (mentioned in her August 2018 crowdcast) she has stopped freezing them, instead opting to put them in the fridge post-harvest. This is because (for unknown reasons) her and her partner Dan were finding they had stomach distress on the sprouts consumed from frozen, compared to if they consumed them fresh.

Rhonda harvests every 3 days, based on research from Jed Fahey, suggesting the sprouts contain more glucoraphanin whilst young.

Dosage

Rhonda suggests that the best data we have on dosage comes from the clinical trials done. She references these 3 in her sulforaphane video:

• 60mg sulforaphane tablets (= 140g fresh broccoli sprouts) – Study showed sulforaphane slowed the doubling rate of a cancer biomarker (known as prostate specific antigen or PSA) by 86%
• 40mg sulforaphane sprout powder (= 100g fresh broccoli sprouts) – Study showed sulforaphane lowered serum triglycerides by 18% and lower oxidized LDL ratio by 13%. Overall, this reduced the trial participants atherogenic index by 50%.
• 40mg sulforaphane sprout powder (= 100g fresh broccoli sprouts) – Study showed sulforaphane reduced inflammation in type 2 diabetics: TNF-alpha by 11%, CRP by 16%.

These studies suggest you want to aim for between 40mg & 60mg sulforaphane (100g to 140g fresh weight sprouts) if you want to emulate their results. This is based on the approximation that 1 gram of fresh weight sprouts is equivalent to 0.425mg of sulforaphane.

To put this into perspective, the quart size Ball mason jars Rhonda uses yield approximately 280g fresh weight per jar when full – which brings 1 jar close to 120mg sulforaphane content.

Rhonda said (on her last Tim Ferriss podcast) she consumes up to 4 ounces (113g) of broccoli sprouts a few times per week.

In terms of consuming them, you’ll probably want to emulate Rhonda, who adds the sprouts to smoothies and blends them in her Blendtec – to mask the taste with other flavors. You want to avoid juicing, as this will discard the pre-biotic fiber that is beneficial to our gut microbiome.

Increasing Broccoli Sprouts Bioavailability

Rhonda had previously created a video on tripling the bioavailability of sulforaphane in the sprouts via heating. However, after discussing the process with John Hopkins researchers Jed Fahey, she has since stopped it – based on Jed suggesting that this is not necessarily. This also avoids the risk of overheating the sprouts, and therefore disabling the myrocinase enzyme – which would be sub-optimal.

Sulforaphane Supplements

Jed Fahey of John Hopkins University, one of the leading researchers in sulforaphane/NRF2, warns us to be careful of which supplement we use. His lab, which has analyzed dozens of supplements over the years, has found that many are terrible, and don’t contain what they say they do. For more info on Jed, see Rhonda’s interview with him.

To complicate matters, there are 3 main ways to consume sulforaphane:

• Pure Sulforaphane – Average bioavailability of 70%*
• Glucoraphanin + Myrosinase – Average bioavailability of 35%*
• Glucoraphanin only – Average bioavailability of 10%*

* Bioavailability numbers come from Jed Fahey’s research at John Hopkins (source).

Below is a list of the sulforaphane supplements tested and used by Jed Fahey’s team at John Hopkins University in their clinical studies:

Pure Sulforaphane – Prostaphane

A French manufacturer called Nutrinov currently makes the only free-form stabilized sulforaphane supplement on the market; Prostaphane. So far it’s only available in France. Rather than containing sulforaphane glucosinolate like most sulforaphane products, it contains a free-form stabilized version of sulforaphane. They market it to help with an aging prostate, but as it’s pure sulforaphane, it has many other benefits.

It’s only sold in France, and so Rhonda was using a service (called moncoinsante.co.uk) to import it into the USA. At the time of writing, that website seems to be down / defunct.

Fortunately, there appears to be a new US based alternative. A company called Superhuman Health have collaborated with the French manufacturers of Prostaphane to offer a near identical product in the USA – called BROQ. Currently this page of their site explains a bit more about their collaboration with the company behind Prostaphane (Nutrinov / Triballat Noyal).

BROQ contains 10mg of sulforpahane per tablet, the same as Prostaphane.

On a recent Q&A she was asked about BROQ, and said whilst in theory it should be the same thing, she will keep using her store of Prostaphane, until she has confirmation from a scientist friend that it’s the same.

Glucoraphanin + Myrosinase – Avmacol

Prior to the introduction of BROQ, the best alternative to Prostaphane was a product by Nutramax Laboratories called Avmacol. It contains glucoraphanin (sulforaphane glucosinolate) extracted from broccoli seeds, alongside the activation enzyme myrocinase.

They currently make it in 2 different strengths – regular strength (green writing) which has ~15 mg of sulforaphane glucinosalate per tablet, and the extra strength version (orange writing) with ~30mg per 1 tablet. At a 35% bioavailability, that would equate to approximately 5.25mg per tablet of sulforaphane for the regular strength, or 10.5mg per tablet for the extra strength.

Glucoraphanin only – Crucera-SGS

The last sulforaphane supplement that has been tested by Jed Fahey and his team is Thorne’s Crucera-SGS. This contains glucoraphanin (sulforaphane glucosinolate, or SGS), but doesn’t contain the additional myrocinase enzyme. Interestingly, our guts do contain bacteria that convert glucoraphanin into sulforaphane. The amounts vary from person to person, and aren’t as optimal as consuming additional active myrocinase.

In summary:

• The 3 supplements above have been tested and used in clinical trials by John Hopkins University – so we can trust they contain what they say, unlike many other broccoli sprout supplements that are ineffective.
• The most bioavailable supplement is Prostaphane/BROQ.
• The next most bioavailable product is Avmacol.

A benefit of using supplements over home grown sprouts is for situations where risk of infection must be minimized – including pregnant mothers and those with compromised immune systems. Home grown sprouts run the risk of bacterial contamination, if they’re not kept completely sterile, whereas sprouts processed into supplements do not carry this risk.

Rhonda’s dosage: 2 tablets of Prostaphane per day

Moringa – another natural source

Rhonda started taking Moringa in 2020 – which stemmed from Jed Fahey’s research at Johns Hopkins. Moringa is derived from the leaves of the Drumstick Tree, which are harvested, dried and then powdered. It contains an isothiocynate with similar properties to sulforaphane, called Moringin.

In Jed’s studies using Moringa, participants consumed it as a cold-brewed tea. This can be made by adding moringa to room temperature water and leaving to stand for at least 10 minutes. They suggest a ratio of 1:100, powder to water. So for example:

• 1 gram of moringa powder to 100 cc of liquid, or
• 5 grams of moringa powder per 8 ounces of liquid, or
• ½ teaspoon of moringa powder per 8 ounces of liquid

The reason for not making a hot tea, is that the myrocinase enzyme in moringa is sensitive to heat, and its important to preserve it.

^ Above image via Jed Fahey

In terms of which Moringa to use, Jed’s studies used Kuli Kuli Moringa. He notes in their FAQs that excessive sunlight or heat after harvest will rapidly degrade some of the phytochemicals and vitamins of interest in the leaves – so it’s worth caution when sourcing.

Suggested dose of moringa?

Whilst quite a lot of money, time and research has been put into looking at sulforaphane and broccoli sprouts, Moringa research is still in its infancy.

To my knowledge there aren’t human studies that have robustly determined what dose of moringa we should be aiming at for various benefits.

The suggestion by Jed (see below) is to use at least a teaspoon of moringa powder for daily dosing.

^ Image via Twitter source

We may need more research to establish any sort of equivalency between moringin and sulforaphane dosing.

Roundup

So we’ve covered why sulforaphane might be of interest, and the different forms that Rhonda takes it in.

If you’ve further questions, please leave them below in the comments.

1. Effect of Broccoli Sprouts and Live Attenuated Influenza Virus on Peripheral Blood Natural Killer Cells: A Randomized, Double-Blind Study – Müller et al. (2016)